42 Comments

  1. Some clear improvements so far (no Harfoots, yay!) , but also a lot of question marks…the one thing that seems clear (so far) is that Galadriel has not learnt a single lesson and is pretty much back in her Guts (Berserk) mode ..I did hope that we are done with the warrior princess after she put on the white robes, lady of light stuff at the end of Season 2. As ever, we'll wait and see – the production, music, cinematography, vfx etc all look pretty remarkable at least!

  2. Saving us from having to endure it is admirable sir. You are providing a valued service.
    "Morgoths Iron crown", so JD Payne and Patrick McKay are just going to ignore the fact that the crown is still round Morgoth's neck in the timeless void.
    At this point, I wouldn't be surprised to see a Mad Titan show up seeking the Silmarils.
    "I am inevitable. I have come for the Three Stones of Light to bring balance to the cosmos."
    Ridiculous? Yes, much like this show.

  3. We are talking about a show full of non-canonical BS, but Durin’s Bane wasn’t really close in rank to Sauron. A. Sauron had a name and is mentioned several times in The Silmarillion; B. Durin’s Bane fled to beneath the Misty Mountains and was never connected to any First Age battles; C. Durin’s Bane never overtly organized forces to do anything outside the Misty Mountains.

  4. I think the need to show the actors face has ruined Sauron a little bit now. Guy did a great job in S1 & S2 but I don't think he needs to be a elf-like form. S1 showed us 5 seconds of fully armoured Sauron and I think that would be better, especially since we'd see him in a fair form again during his time in Númenor.

  5. Some of the creative decisions that have been made in this show have been so dumb that it seems a reasonable to expectation that one day this entire show will be "written off" as another universe à la the comic book world.

  6. omg thank you, I thought I was one of the few who thought shipping of Galadriel and Sauron is a stupid idea. Idk why they need to throw this type of romance lol

  7. From my perspective, the dynamic between Sauron and Galadriel isn’t meant to be a romance or an involvement of any sort. Instead, it represents how Sauron invades a person's mind until they break. We see Galadriel fighting off that influence, which connects directly to the scene where she refuses the One Ring from Frodo and finally feels she has "passed the test." I know this deviates heavily from canon, but it tries to capture a book concept in a new way—much like how Peter Jackson introduced the physical Eye of Sauron in the films, which was also far from the books

  8. I mean… Sauron does have a “thing” for Galadriel. It’s just that that thing is a murderous desire to possess. He also has that thing for Arda. It’s kinda a problem

  9. I can always count on Matt to call that one "ship" out for what it is: inconceivably stupid. Thank you. Looking forward to everything else. Can't wait for the livestreams, Matt. But boy, I hope you do get some well-deserved rest after your travels.

  10. All criticisms aside, Charlie Vickers always delivers as Sauron and if marketing is to be believed and he’s truly the focus this season, then I have high hopes.

    And maybe Sauron got into Khazad-Dum because you and Varking left the door open? Much to think about.

  11. i did not watch season 2 as i felt they took way to much liberty with tolkiens work. and quite frankly butchered it. should i still watch season 2? what is your oppinion?

  12. Amazon clearly hasn’t listened to the fans. They keep changing Tolkien’s work when there’s absolutely no need to.

    Gandalf being in Middle-earth during the forging of the One Ring creates a massive plot hole. In The Fellowship of the Ring, he spends 17 years investigating Bilbo’s ring to establish what it is. If he was around when the One Ring was created, why wouldn’t he already know? Tolkien’s timeline has the wizards arriving in Middle-earth centuries later. (I’m sure they going add something stupid like ohh Gandalf went away or lost his memory)

    And how are we supposed to have Nazgûl without the One Ring’s influence? The Nine Men were corrupted over time through their Rings of Power, ultimately becoming the Nazgûl under Sauron’s influence using The One Ring. So we’ve got half Nazgûl that have been corrupted in a matter of a few years just because Sauron had a hand in making their 9 rings.

    Then there’s the Blue Wizards. Tolkien gave us very little detail about their journeys into the East, which leaves room for creative storytelling. But turning one of them evil so quickly, and potentially having Gandalf encounter them, raises serious questions. The wizards were hand picked by the Valor to help middle-earth and one of them is able to so quickly turn evil (We’ve already had a corrupt wizard it was half The Lord of The Rings. And even then Sarumans corruption took decades if not of centuries and was because of The One Ring)

    There’s a difference between filling in the gaps in Tolkien’s story and changing the story itself. Why can’t they respect the source material while still creating something new? I know Amazon only has the rights to the Appendices of The Return of The King but there’s still enough material to make an awesome show without ruining the timeline.

  13. I am so pumped to see Sauron forging the one ring, the shots look very good…i'm not as opposed to the "something" between Sauron and Galadriel. I don't think the something is a romantic relationship, but I do think there is seduction there, but in the form of power, I think it really highlights how two people can have the same traits or ambitions, but you always have a choice to be good, and I like the exploration!

  14. I really like your channel m8 .. and Im a big big fan. Always looking forward for new videos :). I do get how ur standing on this … and ur mindset… and kudos to u … but i just cant. I gave this show a chance and it let me down … and i just cant have that dose of positivity that u have.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You might like

© 2026 Cantinho do Vídeo - WordPress Video Theme by WPEnjoy