Click this link and use my code JUNIPERDEVBFCM to get 45% off your first payment for boot.dev.
All hope is not lost in the AI cloning of indie games, actually, and this is why.
I make videos on games and game development
Instagram:
Join the Discord:
TikTok:
Contact → juniperdev@rightclick.gg
source

Click this link https://boot.dev/?promo=JUNIPERDEVBFCM and use my code JUNIPERDEVBFCM to get 45% off your first payment for boot.dev.
I think people are blaming the AI for the slop. The slop is not caring about the results – just making something as quick as you can and flushing it out to the internet. Can a vibe coded game be good? I'd say yes, if you follow a similar process as you outlined @10:43. Making a game fun isn't just knowing how to code, it's the time you spend play testing, coming up with new ideas, integrating them, and play testing some more until you find out what works. You can do that same process with AI writing the code, but the reason why you see so much AI slop out there isn't because someone did that, it's because someone thought of an idea for a game and had AI build it, and thought if they released it, they'd just instantly rake in the dough. That's not how any of it works at all.
You hit the nail on the head with the comment that "it's the first version of the game" so of course it's going to suck. Long time SDE here, I used to do Ludum Dares back in 2013-2015 till I got married and had kids and got too busy with family and my day job.
Recently AI has enabled me to pick game dev back up as a hobby but oohhhh boy does it absolutely NOT work the way the this-was-a-one-shot benchmarking youtubers convey it. My first game, which may eventually hit Steam still required hundreds of hours of iteration to get it to a point where I feel a customer would be willing to pay money for it. Not just me playtesting. My friends, family, random acquaintances – and their input was extremely valuable since as a developer you tend to quickly memorize the quirks and become immune to them.
A game is not like a typical application either. Every button must be tactile, have a sound an a look and feel. Every screen, every menu and every level needs music and a tempo that sets the mood. Good game design is closer to directing a movie than any individual discipline that composes the whole.
We may eventually get to a point where AI understands that composition and can mimic it better, but that cohesive whole is a reflection of the game developer's vision and I suspect it will be a long time before AI can replicate a cohesive vision like a person does.
Damn, I feel like making a game now
It will be something similar to music probably. When suno first started to generate it, billions upon billions of AI bros flooded literally any music hosting platform in hopes of becoming extremely popular and rich. And now we just have graveyards of dead AI song accounts, some survived, but never reached any large audiences or success.
Sometimes I just read comments under “I made this game using new Claude ANUS 6.7 model! WOW!” and when I open yt accounts of some AI bros claiming they are also cooking something big thanks to AI, I just see that ~2 years ago same person was trying to generate music, was uploading it on yt, got around 10-100 views and just gave up. Majority of them just lack any perseverance to do anything more than just writing prompts.
4:31 You might like the book “The Most Human Human”
"When standing out becomes harder, the hands who made it matter way more"
I hope so, but this too me is just wishful thinking. The majority of consumers does not care who made something. Standing out does not require a unique perspective, it requires marketing and luck. I see so many games with unique perspectives, art and gameplay, handmade, that get released on Steam, get maybe 2/3 reviews and no one ever sees the game or hears from it again.
It was already near impossible to break through this barrier pre-gen AI and LLMs. Now all the hard work you put in creative decisions and a unique perspective simply gets copied before yours is even out. You're not competing against a shitty copy: The shitty copy competing alone or with other copycats, long before yours comes out. And what will yours look like when it comes out and the market has already been saturated? Right.
Steam will die if they do not enforce AI filters and stronger regulations.
Love the name of the video. I got sick of people who care so much they want to make it others problem
this was a really inspiring video and something i needed to hear
Genius and very intuitive explanation.
The human element will always exist as long as the games are made for us to play. These one-shot / one-prompt ai games will always make the transformation that AI is doing look bad.
Similar to how Unity had a bad reputation for just being used for asset flip games back around 2012ish. Although AI is just 1000x more potent at showing the slop since it's just a couple prompts and you don't even need to spend a lot of money 😂
I totally agree, "human crafted" will become a signifier of quality that gets leaned into more as time goes on, and is already a selling point for many people.
legitimately someone should do a game jam where we all make The Same Game based off a uhh… a prompt…
I'd like to see AI SUCCESSFULLY copy a fully-written story with passion, nuance, and well-developed characters. Go ahead. I dare you, clanker.
"Only I can make it" – But AI can copy anything, which includes your unique creative direction, gameplay choices and so forth.
I fully agree – You can't copy the perspective it comes from – But, however sad it makes me, I think you are greatly overestimating people. Most people don't care. If you're on a developer's discord or even in this comment section: You are not the norm.
Now, whenever you create something, you also have to verify that it was you who made it rather than AI, which adds an extra task.
Thank you for making this, I really appreciate the hopeful perspective as a fellow game dev <3
WhatII came for: methods to spitefully poison AI training data.
What i got: hope for the future
Technical concerns still matter! And that's a good thing
Game development is a fun hobby NOT A JOB anymore there is NO MONEY to be made. Games are free GPT 6.2 Astra makes any indie game free and easily mod able. Want to play hollow knight as sonic? well now you can without even owning the original games. Just get some screen shots explain the mechanics and story and gpt will recreate it all in under 10 prompts. Want GTA6? give it a few more months the next AI models coming soon will keep getting better and better we already made indie devs out of business soon even gta6 will be generatable. Remember MAKING MONEY was a niche one time thing in the games industry many developers never made money their passion project games got like 50 players even AAA studios crash burn and now you have AI letting people recreate indie games at home for free and give unlimited modding abilities customise to their hearts content no limits. Copyright? meh copyright doesn't matter as long as you don't sell the game generated. Copyright never stopped people downloading free movies free cracked versions of games free music basically Piracy won and evolved.
I find the hand made is the new luxury argument quite convincing. I mean it also works for furniture, why not art?
you guys seem to not understand that people don't care about all that stuff, they will buy ai-slop anyways
and in the end you will loose not just money but your time
do not post anything about stuff you're doing until it's finished this is how things are now
I don't see anyone anything worth paying $ 40 + for though lmao. These are all super simple games. Where's the Halo 2 clone ? The TMNT arcade clone ? The Super Mario Galaxy 2 clone ?
11:11
Well we've finally reached THAT part of JD's mind lol.
Thank you for this video, I really feel like I needed to see something like this. The very existence of this seemingly superior coding magic is super demotivating, on top of just graduating into what's straight up comp e/comp sci hell.
I've put a few projects on an indefinite hold because of ai. But you know what, who cares if Claude could do it in 30 mins. It's my project, and I'm going to have fun programming it!
Luckily for me the game project I'm working on now is just going to be MIT licensed opensource, so you won't even need AI to clone it. Unless you're one of those people who needs AI to run "git clone" for you.
To me AI is just asset flip 2.0. It is not meant to do the work for you. Can you use it to learn? can you get examples for art and code? yes, but that should be the limit if at all. If AI makes a game for you, then it isn't your game. You won't have the knowledge to alter it. You bring up Bennett Foddy, I would like to quote him.
"When you’re building a video game, you’re building with ideas, and that can be like working with quick-set cement. You mold your ideas into a certain shape that can be played with, and in the process of playing with them they begin to harden and set until they’re immutable like rock, and at that point you can’t change the world- not without breaking it into pieces and starting fresh with new ideas."
AI is like being given something with the cement already rock solid.
Thank you so much for this video, it has actually relieved a lot of my worry when I think about this awful AI knockoff landscape. THE IMDOMITABLE HUMAN SPIRIT SHALL PREVAIL!!!
It baffles me that so many people look at AI slop and think "AI is bad", rather than "slop is bad". We've always had people looking to make a quick buck by imitating somebody else's success, it's just the means that have changed. Asset flips, play-alikes, cheap knockoffs – the problem has been around as long as gaming has.
I like it thanks
There is no such thing as "AI slop." There's just slop. Humans have been making slop games for decades. AI just makes it easier for more humans to use more efficient tools to make more slop faster. But, here's a thought if you think that AI productions are "slop" by definition: If you use a language like C++ or Python, then you're making "slop" by that same definition because you're not writing in direct machine code, at least assembly. So, because you're using a tool to help you be more efficient and not have to write in assembly (or hex if you're really serious), you're writing "slop." You were lazy. You didn't care enough to write the tightest possible code that runs most efficiently. But that's RIDICULOUS! Tools are tools at whatever level of abstraction!
AI is here to stay. Just as compiled languages made coding more efficient than writing directly in hex, AI is making coding more efficient than writing directly in compiled languages. And, just as humans can write slop C++ code, humans can use AI to produce slop code in whatever language they tell the AI to use. As I said, there's just slop and non-slop, and the tool isn't what makes something slop.
Oh, you might say, but AI makes it easier to write slop. Nope. I ran an enterprise systems company for decades before recently selling it. I've had lots of experience with programmers and have been one myself for decades (actually started on Assembly for the 8086). In ANY language, even Assembly, it's tempting to take shortcuts and produce slop. And I've seen a lot of employees (that didn't make it my company) produce slop in various languages. To use AI really effectively, you actually have to know what's happening under the hood of that layer of abstraction, just as you need to understand memory space and pointers to code in C. There's an ILLUSION of "it's easier to produce AI slop," but I would argue the opposite. It's ALWAYS been easy, and extremely tempting, to produce slop. In fact, the harder the chosen language, the stronger is the temptation to take shortcuts and write slop code. It takes effort, understanding, vision, a systems architecture mentality, and self-discipline to write good code in C or C++ (or other comparable languages). It takes the SAME personal attributes to produce good output from AI. AI can simply make BOTH slop and non-slop happen faster.
Slop has ALWAYS been with us, and it ALWAYS will be with us, because, well, human nature. AI can make it faster to get your slop out there. But slop is just a detectable and detestable, regardless of the toolset used to produce it.
I look at some of this video's examples of "non-slop," and I think, "I would never play that game, because the human made 'art' is just, well, wait for it… SLOPPY." It's lazy. It's the lowest bar to entry that a clearly unskilled human could manage with the chosen toolset. MOST of those games would look and play far better with AI-generated assets!
Pandora's box is OPEN, folks. AI is here to stay, and to stay competitive, devs will learn to do more faster with AI. That FACT has nothing to do with whether the finished products are slop or not. Human effort, skill, vision, truly creative ideas, and attention to detail will always produce finished products that are non-slop. And the opposite attributes will always produce slop, regardless of the chosen toolset.
There's just slop and non-slop. AI is just a tool in the toolbox. There's nothing special about human slop, and the "made with my own two hands" is a RIDICULOUS claim. If you used compiler or interpreter, then you did NOTHING in-principle different from using AI. There's just a continuum of abstraction from the CPU registers (if you even know what those are). So, I have NO sympathy for the assertion that human slop is somehow better than AI slop because it was "made by humans." It actually WASN'T! It was made by machines at a lower level of abstraction than the use of AI. But it was NOT "made with my own two hands." There is NO in-principle "special" level of abstraction.
Cloning is evil, just as how all IP theft has always been evil. Again, there have always been toolkits. Again, AI just makes something faster and easier that has always been with us. Again, the tool isn't the issue.
It's a brave new world. Adapt, produce non-slop most efficiently to stay competitive, or fall behind and whine about "all the AI slop killing everything."
Prada going so hard to prove it was hand drawn instantly took my mind to the quartz crisis.
Mechanical watches became obsolescent overnight. The new hotness was lighter, more accurate, and cheaper.
Swiss manufacturers had to pivot and become marketing companies to stay relevant. What, yesterday was a tool watch, today is a luxury handcrafted good.
Watching this straight after Alanahs Video on the "magic" that's missing from a lot of modern games and especially AI developed games, is making me hopeful.
Because both videos emphasize the art of game development, the small personal stuff that a dev can add, the gift to the player.
This only happens if you iterate for long enough to find the spaces you can make your own.
You can reference previous ideas, that have long since been abandoned, you can reference the next room, because you've already been there.
These are things, that an AI developed game can only ever hope to imitate, because the "creator" never directly interacts with the game or its players/testers.
Cheers Juniper and thank you for highlighting the magic that makes games memorable and unique.
are you a theythem?
If it's not malware, it'll be walware a few months later